The Indian government has announced a significant amendment to the long-term capital gains (LTCG) tax regime that aims to provide substantial relief for property owners. The new proposal allows taxpayers to choose between two tax rates for properties acquired before July 23, 2024: a reduced rate of 12.5% without indexation or a higher rate of 20% with indexation. This change specifically targets the taxation of immovable property, including land and buildings, offering a more flexible tax approach for individuals and Hindu Undivided Families (HuF).
Relief for Property Owners: New Tax Rate Options
Under the revised proposal, property owners will have the option to compute their taxes using either the new scheme or the old scheme. The new scheme offers a lower LTCG tax rate of 12.5% without indexation benefits, while the old scheme retains the 20% tax rate with indexation. This dual-option system allows taxpayers to choose the method that results in the lowest tax liability. This flexibility is designed to address concerns raised by various real estate groups and industry representatives who feared that the removal of indexation would lead to significantly higher tax bills for many property owners, especially those with residential properties.
The indexation adjustment, which previously allowed taxpayers to adjust the purchase price of an asset for inflation, thereby reducing their taxable gains, has been a critical factor in calculating LTCG. The government’s move to remove indexation benefits from real estate, while initially intended to simplify the tax regime and reduce the burden on the economy, faced backlash from stakeholders concerned about the potential financial impact.
Additional Changes for Unlisted Securities
In addition to the relief for property owners, the government is also proposing adjustments to the LTCG tax rate for unlisted securities. The proposed amendments to the Finance Bill, 2024, suggest reverting the LTCG tax rate for unlisted securities purchased before July 23 to 10%, rather than the previously proposed 12.5%. For transfers of unlisted securities or shares of companies not substantially interested to the public, the income tax rates will be:
- 10% for transfers occurring before July 23, 2024
- 12.5% for transfers taking place on or after July 23, 2024
This revision aims to address concerns that the increased tax rate would negatively impact investors in unlisted securities, thereby providing a balanced approach that considers both the interests of investors and the government’s fiscal objectives.
It is essential to note that the proposed LTCG relief is limited to immovable assets such as houses, land, buildings, and unlisted securities. There is no proposed relief for listed equity shares or equity-oriented mutual funds. This exclusion reflects the government’s focus on specific asset classes and its intention to streamline tax benefits for certain types of investments.
The amendment to the Finance Bill, 2024, comes in response to CNBC-TV18’s reports on the reactions from North Block regarding the recent budget announcements. The Finance Minister, Nirmala Sitharaman, had earlier announced the withdrawal of indexation benefits from real estate and reduced the LTCG tax rate from 20% to 12.5% in the Union Budget presented on July 23. The indexation adjustment, which accounted for inflation when calculating gains, had been a key feature of the LTCG tax regime.
Addressing Concerns and Providing Relief for Property Owners
Many real estate associations and industry representatives had urged Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman to reconsider the LTCG changes, citing potential adverse effects on property owners. Following the announcement on July 23, real estate stocks saw a decline and remained in the red, reflecting investor concerns about the implications of the new tax regime. Property owners, particularly those with residential properties, expressed worries about increased tax liabilities due to the removal of indexation benefits.
The government’s revised proposal seeks to alleviate some of the discontent among property owners by providing them with more flexible tax options. By offering a choice between a lower rate without indexation and a higher rate with indexation, the government aims to address these concerns while still pursuing the broader objectives of tax reform. This balanced approach is intended to temper the negative reactions without completely negating the intended benefits of simplifying the LTCG tax regime.
Overall, the amendment to the Finance Bill, 2024, represents a significant shift in the LTCG tax landscape, aiming to provide relief for property owners and investors while addressing various concerns raised by stakeholders. The government’s decision to offer multiple tax rate options reflects its effort to balance fiscal policy objectives with the practical impacts on taxpayers.
You might also be interested in – Vietnam’s real estate mogul ensnared in country’s largest $12.5 billion corruption scandal dubbed ‘Blazing Furnace
